Argument Bookmarks

This chart was created when working with eighth graders. Students were preparing to take a state exam and needed to respond to an isolated writing prompt. Many of the students had great points to support their claims, but lacked organization and elaboration.

1 Argument Bookmark

Why a Bookmark?

This chart is called a bookmark because after instruction I always type up smaller versions of this and turn them into bookmarks for each student. Some teachers have simply taken clear packing tape to quickly laminate these for students. Others have taped them on student desks or inside writing folders. The goal is that students use it frequently so that they begin to automatically remember how to organize their arguments.

Formula Writing:

This bookmark is a definite pattern for writing. I find that most students do need a pattern to begin. Without a pattern, many don’t know where to begin. The great part about introducing a pattern is that once students have a general understanding of an effective way to organize their writing, they can begin to break the pattern and individualize it. Students who struggle with organization, however, still have an effective pattern that they can rely on.

Breaking this into Smaller Chunks:

  1. Create this chart one section at a time. Consider only discussing paragraph one on the first day. Ask students to take an older topic (or assign a mock one) and practice the development of just that paragraph. Build up more each day before applying to an independent topic.

Create charts to provide sentence starters for the different components.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

Article written by Dr. Rozlyn Linder

This is the official blog of Dr. Roz Linder, an academic, K-12 Language Arts Specialist, former elementary school teacher, high school journalism teacher, and all-around rabble rouser. I am interested in how we equip students to compete in a global community that grows increasingly flatter every millisecond and the practical application of communication pedagogy and Common Core standards.Situated at the intersection of cultural, racial, social, and digital literacy, my blog is all about fostering and supporting the recognition that we don’t teach in your grandad’s America and being happy about that. Let's stop telling students what to think or believe, but prepare students to think critically and often.

Please comment with your real name using good manners.

Leave a Reply